Skip to main content

Uprankseo

Clinic staff member at a reception counter beside a laptop, with listing cards floating above

Practo, Justdial and Google Reviews: Which Listings Shape AI Picks for Eye Clinics

Your own website and your Google reviews carry the most weight we can verify when ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude or Grok picks an eye clinic. Practo, Justdial and insurance or society pages matter mainly because their details must match. Every listing has to show the same facts, and the reviews have to be genuine, since the NMC’s October 2026 rules ban bought or manipulated reviews.

Picture a patient in Thane asking, “Which eye hospital near Thane station has good reviews for cataract surgery?” The answer names a few clinics that looked clear and checkable on the pages the tool read. Many of those pages aren’t on your website, which is why the listings matter so much.

Do AI tools read Practo and Justdial at all?

As far as we could find, nobody has measured this for eye clinics in India. The best public data is BrightLocal’s study of 800 local searches in ChatGPT, collected in November 2024 and published that December. Business websites made up 58% of the sources it cited, mentions on other sites 27% and directories 15%. It’s a US study and now two years old, so read the figures as a direction, not a rule.

Man in his thirties seated on a white block, checking a row of star ratings on his phone

One finding surprised us. Yelp, Facebook and Google Maps didn’t appear as directory sources at all. But the same study found that ChatGPT uses review information from Google and Google Maps, so reviews you earn on Google can reach an AI answer even though Google Maps isn’t counted as a directory.

ListingWhat we could verifyWhat to do
Google Business Profile and reviewsGoogle says “more reviews and positive ratings can help your business’s local ranking”. ChatGPT draws on Google review data.Claim it, keep it complete and answer every review
PractoPracto says it publishes “only verified patient stories”. We found no public figure for how often AI tools cite it.Keep doctor profiles, timings and consultation details current
JustdialJustdial’s March 2026 release says its Universal Business Listing manages Google Business Profiles from the Justdial dashboardUse it to keep Google and Justdial identical, then check both
Insurance and society pagesNo public study we could find measures these for eye clinicsAsk for your entry to be correct and current

Our view is that Practo and Justdial are worth keeping accurate, because a mismatch on any site gives an AI tool a reason to doubt your details. Just don’t expect them to do the work Google reviews do. If you haven’t read it yet, our eye hospital guide covers the wider set of fixes.

Why do reviews carry so much weight?

One vendor analysis puts numbers on it. Insites looked at 10,000 US local businesses and found that those named by both ChatGPT and another AI tool averaged 133.4 reviews. Businesses named by neither averaged 10.7. Read it as a warning, not a formula. It’s one vendor’s correlation, and review count moves together with photos, complete profiles and claimed listings, so reviews aren’t the only thing going on.

Google’s own AI features only link to pages that are indexed and eligible to show in Search, so the pages AI reads start there. Our pillar guide on how AI tools decide explains how those pages get picked.

What results can an eye clinic realistically expect?

The closest example we can share is a paediatric surgeon in Santacruz West, Mumbai. Between June and October 2026, their Google reviews went from 9 to 25, their Google Maps listing moved from outside the top 10 to #3, and monthly impressions rose from 2,485 to 5,209. Those are Google results, not AI answers, and they’re one practice’s numbers, not a promise. You can read the full case study.

How do you earn reviews without breaking the rules?

Google is strict about this. Its contribution policy bars incentives for reviews, including discounts, gifts and credits, and it bars offering anything to change or remove a negative review. Businesses also may not selectively solicit positive reviews or discourage negative ones.

The NMC adds its own limits for doctors and hospitals. Its October 2026 guidelines bar procuring or manipulating reviews and ratings, and they say patient consent alone doesn’t make a testimonial or promotional patient story acceptable. The official NMC notice and a Medical Dialogues summary set out the details, and any review campaign is worth running past your legal adviser first.

In practice that means:

  • Ask every patient the same way after each visit, not only the happy ones.
  • Reply to every review politely, and never discuss a patient’s treatment in a reply.
  • Don’t post patient stories as promotion on your website or social pages.

Are Practo and Justdial worth the effort?

Practo says it publishes only verified patient stories, runs guidelines to keep testimonials fair and factually correct, and doesn’t accept promotional comments from a doctor’s close acquaintances. Justdial says its platform is backed by 155.7 million ratings and reviews, and that its review management tool offers AI-driven suggestions for replies. Both are company claims. We didn’t find independent data on how either site feeds AI answers for eye clinics.

There’s one rule to check before you buy anything. The NMC guidelines tell healthcare platforms that host doctors to prohibit paid ranking of doctors and keep their listing practices transparent. A paid “featured” slot on a directory could fall under that, so get written advice from your legal adviser before you pay for one.

Which details must match everywhere?

Once reviews are coming in, the basic facts have to agree. Start with Google, then check Practo, Justdial and the insurance or society pages. On each one, compare the same five things: name, address, phone, timings and the list of doctors.

Four listings to check for an eye clinic: Google, Practo, Justdial and insurer pages

An old Justdial number, or a doctor who has left but still shows on Practo, is enough to make an AI tool hesitate. Pick one person to own every listing and check them each quarter. If you run more than one branch, our local SEO service covers listings for clinics with several sites.

How do you check whether AI recommends your eye clinic?

Test it once a month. Open ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude and Grok in fresh chats and ask what your patients ask:

  • “Which eye hospital in Thane has good reviews for cataract surgery?”
  • “Which eye clinic near Kalyan station do patients recommend for glaucoma?”
  • “Where can I get LASIK in Navi Mumbai with good reviews and cashless insurance?”
  • “Who is a well-reviewed eye surgeon in Thane for children?”

Note whether your clinic is named, which listings each answer cites and what the reviews say. If an answer quotes an old Practo page or a wrong phone number, that’s your next job. If the answer is thin, our AI SEO service covers the fixes.

Frequently asked questions

Do Practo and Justdial listings help AI tools name my eye clinic? No public study we could find measures this for eye clinics. Keep both accurate anyway, because one mismatched phone number gives an AI tool a reason to doubt your details.

Can we ask patients for Google reviews? Yes, if you ask every patient in the same way and don’t offer anything in return. Google bars incentives and selective requests, and the NMC bars buying or manipulating reviews. Check your process with your legal adviser before you start.

Should we suggest what patients write in their reviews? No. Ask in the language your patient is most comfortable with, but don’t hand over a script or ask for particular content. Google’s policy says businesses shouldn’t request specific content, so keep the request to an honest review and nothing more.

Can we pay Justdial or Practo for a top spot? Ask first. The NMC guidelines tell healthcare platforms to prohibit paid ranking of doctors, so a paid featured slot may not be allowed for your clinic. Get written advice before you buy any placement.

How many reviews do we need before AI tools name us? There’s no verified number. The vendor analysis found businesses named by AI had far more reviews on average, but that’s correlation, not a threshold. Steady, genuine reviews over time matter more than hitting a target.

Should we reply to negative reviews? Yes, politely and briefly. Never confirm or discuss a patient’s treatment in a reply, and never offer a discount or gift to change or remove a bad review, because Google treats that as an incentive.

How long before a change shows up in AI answers? We haven’t found a verified timeline. Re-test monthly and note what changes.

Find out what AI says about your clinic

We’ll check what ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude and Grok tell your patients, which listings they cite, and what needs fixing to stay inside the NMC rules. It’s free. Request your AI visibility check.

Picture of Author<br>Ramkumar Srinivasan, Founder, UpRankSEO

Author
Ramkumar Srinivasan, Founder, UpRankSEO

A passionate entrepreneur with strong functional skills, digital strategist, product development expert & UI/UX visualizer.

View All Posts

Success

THANK YOU!
We have received your request. Our experts will get in touch with you in a day or two.

Get Free SEO Proposal

Share your domain name, our experts will do a free audit and share best proposal with you.