Can a local broker compete with 99acres and MagicBricks in AI answers? Yes, but not on their ground. The big portals win on listing volume and brand recognition, and a small firm can’t out-spend them. A local broker wins the questions that depend on place and trust: a named agent, clear pages for each locality and project, and proof from other sites.
Housing.com is now inside ChatGPT too, so you can’t ignore portals. This guide shows where a broker in Thane, Navi Mumbai or Kalyan can get named, where it’s smarter not to compete, and what MahaRERA’s rules mean for your ads.
Are 99acres and MagicBricks already inside AI tools?
Partly. Recently, Housing.com launched its native property search experience inside ChatGPT, where buyers can search, refine their preferences and compare options through a conversation. CXOToday reports the launch. The Whalesbook report names the rivals in the same breath, calling them “established players like 99acres (part of Info Edge) and MagicBricks (part of the Times Group)”.
When we checked, we couldn’t find a comparable ChatGPT search from 99acres or MagicBricks. That can change within a month, so check again before you plan around it. We also couldn’t find published figures on how often AI tools cite either portal for local property questions. Be wary of anyone who quotes one, us included.

What do AI tools read when a buyer asks about a broker?
Take a buyer in Kalyan West who types, “Which broker can help me buy a resale 2BHK near the station?” The AI runs a web search, reads a few pages and names the agents whose pages answer that question most clearly. No AI company publishes its exact method. Our guide on how AI tools decide which business to recommend covers the general mechanics.
Google does explain how its local results are ranked, though, and its three factors make a useful guide. Relevance is how well a Business Profile matches what someone is searching for. Distance is how far each business is from the person searching. Prominence means how well-known a business is.

Prominence is where the portals have the edge. Almost every buyer in Thane has heard of 99acres. Relevance and distance are where a local broker can do well. A page that says you handle resale 2BHKs near Kalyan West is more relevant to that buyer than a citywide search page, and your office is close to them in a way no portal can match.
Map rankings don’t decide AI answers, though. In a recent test in two US cities by Ryan Doser, four AI assistants made 250 recommendations, and only 22.8% of them were in Google’s top three map results. A strong map position helps, but it doesn’t settle the answer.
Where do portals win, and where can a local broker?
| Signal | What the big portals have | Where a local broker can win |
|---|---|---|
| Brand (prominence) | A name most buyers already know | A named agent with a MahaRERA registration number you can show |
| Relevance | Listings across many areas, sorted by filters | Pages for each locality and project you know well |
| Distance | A citywide search box | Your office and Google Business Profile in the areas buyers search |
| Proof | A large listing count | Reviews that name the locality, and deals you can describe |
Portals will keep their brand edge, and you won’t close that gap in a year. Don’t waste effort there. Put it into relevance and distance, where your knowledge of Thane, Navi Mumbai and Kalyan is a real asset.
What do the MahaRERA rules mean for your ads?
If you broker flats in RERA-registered projects, MahaRERA’s rules cover what you show buyers. Under RERA, an agent must be registered before facilitating the sale or purchase of any unit in a registered project. A registered agent must also quote its registration number on documents relating to advertising, marketing, selling or purchase, and display its certificate number at its principal office and branches.
A recent MahaRERA circular also covers advertising. Press reports say each ad must show the project’s registration number, the MahaRERA website address and a QR code that opens the project’s page. These details go in the top right and in type at least as large as the contact details. The Realty Today also covers this. The directive applies to agents as well as developers. We couldn’t open the circular itself, so check the current text on the MahaRERA website or with your legal adviser before you change your ads.
Why does this matter for AI answers? An AI tool can’t check your ad against the rules, but a buyer can. A registration number that sits on your listing pages is a fact someone can verify, and that’s what a recommendation needs.
How do you show up for local buyers?
Start with your own site. Give each locality you work in its own page, such as Majiwada, Hiranandani Estate or Kalyan West. Say which projects you know, which buyers you handle and how you’re registered. Two plain paragraphs per page are enough to start. Our AI SEO service and local SEO plans cover the page work and the listings.
Keep your name, office address and phone number identical on your site, your Google Business Profile and every portal profile. Google says that “businesses with complete and accurate info are more likely to show up in local search results”. If two listings disagree, it’s harder for any tool to be sure which firm you are.
Reviews come next. Google also says that “more reviews and positive ratings can help your business’s local ranking”. Ask buyers for a review after a completed deal, and reply to every one. Never buy reviews or write them yourself.
Check your robots.txt as well. OpenAI says OAI-SearchBot is used to surface websites in ChatGPT’s search features, and that sites opted out of it “will not be shown in ChatGPT search answers”. Changes to robots.txt can take about 24 hours to apply.
One of our clients is a RERA-registered consultancy in Hiranandani Estate, Thane. Over a few months, all 19 of its keywords reached page one of Google, and 17 of them moved into the top 5, up from 3. Its Google Maps calls reached 47 a month, and “real estate agent near me” went from #2 to #1. Monthly impressions rose from 669 to 1,359.

Those are Google Search and Maps results, not AI answers. We haven’t measured how much of that carries over, so read it as a sign of what local work can do, not a promise about ChatGPT.
How do you check whether AI recommends your brokerage?
Test it once a month. Open ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude and Grok in fresh chats and ask the questions your buyers ask:
- “Which broker in Majiwada, Thane, can help me buy a resale 2BHK?”
- “Which RERA-registered agent in Kalyan West handles flats under ₹1 crore?”
- “Should I buy a flat in Navi Mumbai through a local broker or on 99acres?”
- “Who gets the best reviews for buying near Thane station?”
Write down whether you’re named, which sites the answer leans on and whether it gets your locality right. If a portal is cited and you aren’t, look at what that portal page says that yours doesn’t.
Frequently asked questions
Can a broker pay ChatGPT or Gemini to recommend them? No. The answers come from the pages these tools read. You can improve those pages and earn mentions on other sites, but there’s no paid spot in the answer.
Does ChatGPT show 99acres and MagicBricks listings? We couldn’t find published data on how often it does for local questions. Housing.com launched a property search inside ChatGPT recently, so some portal listings can now reach the chat. Test your own localities each month to see what gets named.
Should I stop listing on the portals? No. Keep them for reach and enquiries. Just make sure your own site, your Google Business Profile and your portal profiles give the same name, phone number and RERA number.
Does my RERA number help AI tools recommend me? It doesn’t guarantee anything, and we haven’t seen any AI company say it gives extra weight. But MahaRERA rules require agents to quote their registration number on advertising and sale documents. That makes it a checkable fact, so it belongs on your listing pages.
Can a small broker beat a portal in AI answers? For a question about a specific locality, project or buyer type, yes. For a broad question like “which is the best property site in India”, the portal will usually have the edge. Aim for the specific questions your buyers actually ask.
How long before a local broker shows up? Changes to robots.txt take about 24 hours to reach OpenAI’s search crawler, but rankings take longer. Our Hiranandani Estate case study moved within three months. Those were Google results, though, not AI answers.
Find out what AI says about your brokerage
We’ll ask ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude and Grok the questions your buyers ask, show you which brokers get named, and point out what’s holding your locality pages back. It’s free. Request your AI visibility check.